• Question: What's the topic that psychologists are confused about and trying to figure out the problem of?

    Asked by anon-237445 to Peter, Mhairi, Madeleine, Catherine, Andrew on 19 Mar 2020.
    • Photo: Madeleine Pownall

      Madeleine Pownall answered on 19 Mar 2020:


      There a huge number of debates happening all over psychology at any given time.
      One of the sources of confusion/debate/discussion that I’m particularly interested in (as both a psychologist and just a person!) is the idea of ‘hard-wired’ brain differences between men and women. This been a huge source of debate and discussion over recent years – and the ‘gender differences’ debate started years and years ago (we’re talking back to medieval times…)

      Professor Gina Rippon is a psychologist who has asked us to consider how these ‘brain differences’ between men and women might be more about gender stereotypes and our interpretation of data, rather than clear-cut differences. Professor Rippon doesn’t necessarily argue that there are absolutely no differences between the female and male brain, she just thinks that all brains are different, so to focus on small differences between men and women does not make sense in the context of huge individual differences. Some people (myself included!) think that looking at ‘hard wired’ brain differences by gender may ignore some much more interesting ideas, such as gender norms (which are like stereotypes), and wider brain differences across people.

      Corelia Fine is another psychologist whose done fascinating work in this area. You can read an interview with her here: https://thepsychologist.bps.org.uk/volume-23/edition-11/battle-sex-differences

      There are, of course, other psychologists who argue that there are fundamental brain differences and this shapes our social world (men are hardwired to be good at X, women are hardwired to be good at Y) but I think this will continue to be challenged!

    • Photo: Peter Kinderman

      Peter Kinderman answered on 19 Mar 2020:


      Psychology covers all of human behaviour, from the internal working of the brain (and questions such the well-known ‘nature / nurture’ problem – are we born like this, or do we learn to be like that?) through to politics (and why we end up voting for leaders who are obviously both morally corrupt and incompetent). So, there isn’t really one topic…
      I think one of the most interesting and challenging topic is the question of where consciousness comes from. This isn’t just the question of how life works (how a agglomeration of chemicals becomes alive), but (even then) how a collection of cells and chemicals, proteins and electrical depolarisation can end up with a brain (and eyes) that are capable of recognising ourselves in a mirror.
      Nobody really has an idea… but we’re working on it!

    • Photo: Andrew McNeill

      Andrew McNeill answered on 20 Mar 2020:


      Social psychology is currently going through a “replication crisis” where it has become clear that many classic studies in psychology don’t produce the same results when repeated. I suppose this means that the big question facing psychologists is: can we *really* predict human behaviour? If people can always do something differently (free choice) and we are always influenced by the environment around us that is constantly changing, then it is very difficult to consistently predict how people will behave.

Comments